Alexander PaulNantucket is one of America’s most prestigious island destinations, attracting travelers with its charming cobblestone streets, historic architecture, pristine beaches, luxury boutiques, and award-winning restaurants. Located approximately 30 miles off the coast of Cape Cod, Massachusetts, Nantucket effortlessly combines New England charm with sophisticated luxury.
Whether you’re planning a romantic honeymoon, a relaxing family vacation, or a luxurious weekend escape, choosing the right hotel can transform your entire experience.
This guide explores the top 50 luxury hotels in Nantucket, highlighting their unique features, premium amenities, dining experiences, and reasons they continue to impress discerning travelers from around the world.
Top 50 Luxury Hotels In Nantucket
1. White Elephant Nantucket
White Elephant is arguably the most iconic luxury hotel on Nantucket. Overlooking the harbor, this award-winning property has welcomed celebrities, business leaders, and vacationers seeking refined coastal elegance for decades.
The hotel features beautifully designed rooms, luxurious suites, private cottages, and even upscale residences for longer stays. Every room combines classic Nantucket style with modern comfort.
Guests can relax by the waterfront, enjoy complimentary bicycles, or unwind in beautifully landscaped gardens.
Highlights
- Harborfront location
- Luxury cottages
- Complimentary BMW transportation
- Award-winning waterfront restaurant
- Concierge services
- Fitness center
- Family-friendly atmosphere
Best For
Couples, honeymooners, luxury family vacations, and waterfront lovers.
2. The Wauwinet
Located on the northeastern side of Nantucket, The Wauwinet offers an exclusive adults-oriented luxury retreat away from the busy downtown area.
Surrounded by both the Atlantic Ocean and Nantucket Bay, this elegant boutique hotel provides breathtaking water views from nearly every direction.
The peaceful atmosphere makes it ideal for romantic getaways, anniversaries, and luxury escapes.
Guests appreciate the attentive service, sophisticated décor, and tranquil surroundings.
Highlights
- Private beach access
- Luxury waterfront rooms
- Complimentary boat shuttle
- Gourmet dining
- Peaceful environment
- Kayaking opportunities
- Beautiful sunsets
Best For
Romantic vacations and couples seeking privacy.
3. Jared Coffin House
History meets luxury at Jared Coffin House, one of Nantucket’s most famous historic hotels.
Originally built in the 1800s by successful whaling merchant Jared Coffin, the building has been carefully restored while preserving its timeless elegance.
Located in the heart of downtown Nantucket, guests are within walking distance of museums, restaurants, shopping districts, galleries, and the harbor.
Despite its historic appearance, rooms feature modern luxury amenities including premium bedding, elegant bathrooms, Wi-Fi, and stylish furnishings.
Highlights
- Historic landmark
- Downtown location
- Elegant colonial architecture
- Spacious luxury rooms
- Fine dining nearby
- Rich island history
Best For
History lovers and travelers wanting to stay in downtown Nantucket.
4. Nantucket Hotel & Resort
Often considered one of the island’s finest family-friendly luxury properties, Nantucket Hotel & Resort blends traditional New England architecture with upscale modern hospitality.
The hotel features beautifully decorated guest rooms, spacious suites, heated swimming pools, outdoor fire pits, wellness facilities, and daily family activities.
Guests can enjoy complimentary transportation around the island and access to nearby beaches.
Families especially appreciate the children’s programs, making it one of the most versatile luxury resorts on Nantucket.
Highlights
- Heated outdoor pools
- Spa treatments
- Family activities
- Fitness center
- Luxury suites
- Complimentary beach shuttle
- Evening entertainment
Best For
Families, group vacations, and extended stays.
5. The Cottages & Lofts by The Nantucket Hotel
Travelers seeking additional space and privacy often choose The Cottages & Lofts.
Designed for families, groups, and longer vacations, these luxurious accommodations provide residential-style living while maintaining full access to the services and amenities of The Nantucket Hotel.
Guests enjoy gourmet kitchens, spacious living rooms, multiple bedrooms, private patios, and premium furnishings.
This option combines the comfort of a private home with the luxury of a five-star resort.
Highlights
- Luxury cottages
- Full kitchens
- Large living spaces
- Resort amenities
- Private outdoor areas
- Family-friendly accommodations
- Premium concierge service
Best For
Large families, extended vacations, and travelers seeking home-like luxury.
6. 21 Broad Hotel
Located in the heart of downtown Nantucket, 21 Broad Hotel is a contemporary boutique hotel that blends modern sophistication with the island’s timeless charm. Its sleek design, luxurious interiors, and personalized service make it a favorite among couples and business travelers.
The hotel features stylish guest rooms equipped with smart technology, plush bedding, rainfall showers, and elegant décor. Guests also enjoy complimentary breakfast, afternoon refreshments, and access to outdoor relaxation spaces.
Being just a short walk from the ferry terminal, beaches, restaurants, and boutique shops makes 21 Broad Hotel an excellent choice for visitors who want convenience without sacrificing luxury.
Highlights
- Prime downtown location
- Contemporary boutique design
- Complimentary gourmet breakfast
- Outdoor courtyard with fire pit
- Modern luxury rooms
- Walking distance to attractions
- Excellent concierge service
Best For
Couples, solo travelers, and weekend visitors looking for modern luxury.
7. Union Street Inn
Union Street Inn offers an intimate luxury experience in one of Nantucket’s beautifully restored historic homes. Combining classic architecture with upscale amenities, the inn creates a welcoming atmosphere for guests who appreciate refined comfort.
Each room is individually decorated with elegant furnishings, premium linens, luxurious bathrooms, and tasteful coastal-inspired décor. Guests enjoy freshly prepared breakfasts, afternoon snacks, and attentive hospitality throughout their stay.
The quiet location provides a peaceful retreat while remaining close to downtown attractions.
Highlights
- Historic boutique inn
- Personalized guest service
- Elegant room décor
- Gourmet breakfast included
- Beautiful garden seating
- Peaceful surroundings
- Walking distance to downtown
Best For
Couples and travelers seeking a quiet, elegant getaway.
8. Greydon House
Greydon House is one of Nantucket’s most stylish luxury boutique hotels. Housed in a beautifully restored historic building, it seamlessly combines vintage character with contemporary design.
The rooms feature custom furniture, luxury bedding, marble bathrooms, and artistic décor inspired by global travel and coastal New England.
One of its biggest attractions is its acclaimed restaurant, which serves fresh seafood, locally sourced ingredients, and expertly crafted cocktails.
Guests appreciate its central location, making it easy to explore Nantucket’s restaurants, galleries, beaches, and shopping streets.
Highlights
- Chic boutique atmosphere
- Award-winning restaurant
- Stylish designer interiors
- Luxury marble bathrooms
- Prime downtown location
- Exceptional dining experience
- Personalized hospitality
Best For
Food lovers, couples, and luxury travelers who appreciate boutique accommodations.
9. The Veranda House
Following an extensive restoration, The Veranda House has re-established itself as one of Nantucket’s premier luxury boutique hotels. The property retains its historic charm while offering modern comforts and upscale amenities.
Guests are welcomed into elegantly designed rooms featuring luxurious bedding, contemporary bathrooms, tasteful coastal décor, and thoughtful touches that create a relaxing atmosphere.
Its inviting outdoor spaces, including gardens and verandas, provide ideal places to unwind after exploring the island.
Highlights
- Beautifully restored historic property
- Elegant guest rooms
- Quiet garden spaces
- Premium hospitality
- Downtown location
- Complimentary breakfast
- Cozy outdoor seating
Best For
Couples, honeymooners, and travelers seeking classic Nantucket elegance.
10. Life House, Nantucket
Life House, Nantucket offers a fresh interpretation of luxury hospitality. Designed with younger luxury travelers in mind, the hotel combines boutique sophistication with a relaxed island atmosphere.
Its stylish interiors feature natural materials, coastal-inspired colors, custom furnishings, and thoughtfully curated artwork. Guests enjoy comfortable accommodations, communal gathering spaces, and easy access to Nantucket’s most popular attractions.
The hotel emphasizes personalized service and modern conveniences while maintaining the welcoming spirit of a traditional island inn.
Highlights
- Trendy boutique design
- Modern luxury amenities
- Stylish communal spaces
- Personalized guest experience
- Comfortable designer rooms
- Excellent downtown location
- Contemporary coastal ambiance
Best For
Young professionals, couples, and modern luxury travelers.
Full List
| Rank | Luxury Hotel | Location |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | White Elephant Nantucket | Nantucket Harbor |
| 2 | The Wauwinet | Wauwinet, Nantucket |
| 3 | Jared Coffin House | Downtown Nantucket |
| 4 | Nantucket Hotel & Resort | Downtown Nantucket |
| 5 | The Cottages & Lofts by The Nantucket Hotel | Downtown Nantucket |
| 6 | 21 Broad Hotel | Downtown Nantucket |
| 7 | Union Street Inn | Downtown Nantucket |
| 8 | Greydon House | Downtown Nantucket |
| 9 | The Veranda House | Downtown Nantucket |
| 10 | Life House, Nantucket | Downtown Nantucket |
| 11 | Faraway Nantucket | Downtown Nantucket |
| 12 | Hotel Pippa | Downtown Nantucket |
| 13 | Brass Lantern Inn | Downtown Nantucket |
| 14 | Chapman House | Downtown Nantucket |
| 15 | Cliff Lodge | Cliff Road, Nantucket |
| 16 | Martin House Inn | Downtown Nantucket |
| 17 | Seven Sea Street Inn | Downtown Nantucket |
| 18 | Sherburne Inn | Downtown Nantucket |
| 19 | 76 Main Ink Press Hotel | Main Street, Nantucket |
| 20 | The Centerboard Nantucket | Center Street, Nantucket |
| 21 | Anchor Inn | Downtown Nantucket |
| 22 | Blue Iris by Life House | Downtown Nantucket |
| 23 | The Beachside at Nantucket | North Shore, Nantucket |
| 24 | Periwinkle Inn | Downtown Nantucket |
| 25 | Nesuto Nantucket (Boutique Stay) | Nantucket |
| 26 | Hawthorn House | Downtown Nantucket |
| 27 | The Barnacle Inn | Downtown Nantucket |
| 28 | White Elephant Residences | Nantucket Harbor |
| 29 | The Cottages at Boat Basin | Nantucket Harbor |
| 30 | Harborview Nantucket | Nantucket Harbor |
| 31 | 29 India House | India Street, Nantucket |
| 32 | The Regatta Inn | Nantucket |
| 33 | The Chestnut House | Downtown Nantucket |
| 34 | The Summer House Collection | Nantucket |
| 35 | The Swain House | Downtown Nantucket |
| 36 | Pineapple Inn | Downtown Nantucket |
| 37 | The Rosemary House | Downtown Nantucket |
| 38 | The Carlisle House Inn | Downtown Nantucket |
| 39 | The Manor House Nantucket | Nantucket |
| 40 | The Nantucket Resort Collection | Various Downtown Locations |
| 41 | Roberts Collection Hotel | Downtown Nantucket |
| 42 | 76 Main Suites | Main Street, Nantucket |
| 43 | The Island House Nantucket | Downtown Nantucket |
| 44 | The Shell House | Nantucket |
| 45 | Cliffside Guest House | Cliff Area, Nantucket |
| 46 | Pleasant Street Inn | Downtown Nantucket |
| 47 | Center Street Inn | Center Street, Nantucket |
| 48 | Orange Street Inn | Orange Street, Nantucket |
| 49 | Fair Street Guest House | Fair Street, Nantucket |
| 50 | Historic Luxury Guest House Nantucket | Downtown Nantucket |
Comparison Table
| Hotel | Location | Best For | Luxury Highlights |
|---|---|---|---|
| White Elephant Nantucket | Harborfront | Families & Couples | Waterfront views, cottages, fine dining |
| The Wauwinet | Northeastern Shore | Romantic Escapes | Private beach, luxury waterfront setting |
| Jared Coffin House | Downtown | History Lovers | Historic charm, central location |
| Nantucket Hotel & Resort | Downtown | Families | Pools, spa, children’s activities |
| The Cottages & Lofts | Downtown | Extended Stays | Full kitchens, spacious luxury homes |
| 21 Broad Hotel | Downtown | Couples | Modern boutique luxury, fire pit |
| Union Street Inn | Downtown | Quiet Getaways | Personalized service, gourmet breakfast |
| Greydon House | Downtown | Food Lovers | Award-winning restaurant, designer interiors |
| The Veranda House | Downtown | Honeymooners | Historic elegance, garden retreat |
| Life House, Nantucket | Downtown | Young Luxury Travelers | Contemporary boutique style |
How to Choose the Right Luxury Hotel in Nantucket
With so many exceptional accommodations, selecting the right hotel depends on your travel style and priorities.
- For romantic escapes: The Wauwinet and The Veranda House offer privacy, elegant surroundings, and intimate atmospheres.
- For families: Nantucket Hotel & Resort and The Cottages & Lofts provide spacious accommodations and family-friendly amenities.
- For waterfront luxury: White Elephant Nantucket delivers spectacular harbor views and premium services.
- For history enthusiasts: Jared Coffin House combines timeless architecture with modern comfort.
- For boutique hotel lovers: Greydon House, Union Street Inn, 21 Broad Hotel, and Life House offer unique personalities and stylish accommodations.
Booking well in advance—especially for summer travel—is recommended, as Nantucket’s luxury hotels are in high demand during peak season.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What is the most luxurious hotel in Nantucket?
Many travelers consider White Elephant Nantucket to be the island’s most iconic luxury hotel thanks to its waterfront location, premium accommodations, and exceptional service.
2. Which luxury hotel is best for couples?
The Wauwinet is widely regarded as one of the best choices for couples due to its peaceful setting, private beach access, and romantic atmosphere.
3. Are luxury hotels in Nantucket family-friendly?
Yes. Properties like Nantucket Hotel & Resort and The Cottages & Lofts offer family-oriented amenities, spacious accommodations, and activities for children.
4. When is the best time to visit Nantucket?
The most popular time to visit is from late spring through early fall (May to September), when the weather is warm and most attractions, restaurants, and outdoor activities are fully operational.
5. Do Nantucket luxury hotels offer beach access?
Many luxury hotels either provide direct beach access or complimentary transportation to nearby beaches, allowing guests to enjoy the island’s stunning coastline with ease.
Related
Conclusion
Nantucket remains one of the most exclusive island destinations in the United States, offering an unforgettable blend of coastal beauty, rich history, and world-class hospitality. Whether you’re seeking a romantic retreat overlooking the harbor, a family-friendly resort with premium amenities, or a chic boutique hotel in the heart of downtown, the island has a luxury accommodation to match every preference.
From the iconic White Elephant Nantucket and the serene elegance of The Wauwinet to the contemporary charm of Life House, Nantucket, each property provides a distinctive experience while maintaining the exceptional service and comfort that define luxury travel.
No matter which hotel you choose, your stay in Nantucket promises refined accommodations, memorable dining experiences, breathtaking scenery, and the timeless charm that has made this island a favorite destination for discerning travelers from around the world.